top of page

Who Says 'Say!' ?

  • philhoraia
  • Feb 27, 2023
  • 1 min read

Updated: Aug 9, 2024

In a number of passages a sentence is introduced with the word 'Say!'. Whereas this is supposedly Allah giving a command as to what to say to its boss, there is no internal evidence that it is indeed Allah. Moreover, why are there passages in which he is directed to say such-and-such? Were those directions ONLY what he was to say to people?



Not directly related to this issue but which should be of interest to readers is S 21:4. The Hafs version of the Quran, along with a few others, says: "He said [Qala]: My lord knows the speech in the sky and the Earth. And he is the hearer, the learned." whereas the Warsh, along with other versions, has: "Say [Qul]: My lord knows the speech in the sky and the Earth. And he is the hearer, the learned." In the Warsh there is a command to say what comes after the verb. Obviously, despite what a Muslim will say, the meanings are different. Only one of the readings can be correct.


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
The Qarin

Chronological order: S 50:23 (34th) His qarin said: This is what is ready with me. S 50:27 His qarin said: Our lord, I did not make him oppress but he was in far error. S 37:51 (56th) A speaker among

 
 
 
Yahya's Sujud To Isa in the Womb

From Al-Qurtubi's tafsir on S 3:39 And Al-Tabari has mentioned that Maryam, when she was pregnant with Isa, her sister too was pregnant with Yahya; and her sister came to visit and said: Maryam, did y

 
 
 
Thorns Or Fruit?

In this post we shall be looking at S 56:29. And clustered talh Al-Baghawi: (And clustered talh ) That is: bananas--its singular is talhah --from most of the mufassirun. And Al-Hasan said: It is not

 
 
 

Comments


Post: Blog2_Post
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

©2021 by It Is A Noble Messenger's Speech. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page